Recent Blog Posts

pizza restaurant
April 2, 2026
Are you interested in visiting your local pizza restaurant? Here are some of the most popular pizza toppings that you should consider trying.

Authentic New York Pizza And More

St. Augustine, FL

Takeout & Delivery Available

Family Recipes

Locally Sourced Ingredients

Hours:

Serving Up a Tasty Italian Feast

Craving a slice of the Big Apple right here in St. Augustine? Look no further than Vinny's Pizza! We've been serving up mouthwatering, authentic New York-style pizza for more than 25 years, using time-honored family recipes and the freshest, locally sourced ingredients. Our commitment to quality and flavor has made us a beloved fixture in the St. Augustine community. Give us a call if you want the best pizza delivery in St Augustine, FL.

At Vinny's, we're all about bringing families together over great food. Whether you're dining in, grabbing a quick slice on the go, or feeding a crowd, we've got you covered. Our menu features a variety of classic and creative pizza options, as well as other Italian favorites that'll transport your taste buds straight to Little Italy. And the best part? We offer flexible ordering options to fit your busy lifestyle, including in-store pickup, curbside service, and the
best pizza delivery in St Augustine, FL. Ready to experience the Vinny's difference? Contact us today, and let's get your pizza party started!

Vinny's Pizza

Why Choose Us

Black verified badge with a white checkmark.

Takeout & Delivery Available

Black, star-shaped badge with white checkmark and dot.

Family Recipes

Black verified badge with white checkmark.

Locally Sourced Ingredients

Black, irregular badge with a white checkmark.

Same-Day Catering Available

Black and white verified badge with a checkmark.

Freshest Ingredients

Black check mark icon.

Family-Style Meals & Box Lunches Available

Spaghetti with meatballs in tomato sauce, sprinkled with Parmesan cheese, in a white bowl.

Catering

Planning a big event? Let Vinny's take care of the food! Our catering service is perfect for gatherings of all sizes, with options to feed up to 50 hungry guests. We offer same-day and short-notice catering for those last-minute soirées, because we know life doesn't always stick to a schedule. From family-style meals to individually boxed lunches, we've got a variety of options to suit your needs and keep your guests raving about the food long after the party's over.
Three stuffed Italian bread rolls on a wooden board, with tomatoes and basil.

Menu

Our menu is a love letter to New York-style pizza, featuring a perfect balance of crispy crust, gooey cheese, and savory toppings. We use only the highest-quality products and locally sourced ingredients to ensure that every bite is bursting with flavor. From classic Margherita to adventurous specialty pies, there's something for everyone at Vinny's. And don't forget to check out our selection of appetizers, salads, and Italian entrees – they're the perfect complement to your pizza feast!

A black speech bubble with four horizontal lines inside, indicating text.

Here's what our satisfied customers are saying...

At Vinny's Pizza, we take pride in providing exceptional pizza and complementary offerings to our customers. We would be grateful if you could share your thoughts about our offerings with others. Your feedback helps us improve and helps others make informed decisions. Please take a moment to leave a review of Vinny's Pizza and let others know what you think.

Recent Blog Posts

pizza restaurant
April 2, 2026
Are you interested in visiting your local pizza restaurant? Here are some of the most popular pizza toppings that you should consider trying.

Frequently Asked Questions

At Vinny's Pizza, we work hard to make every ordering experience simple, flavorful, and convenient. Below are answers to some of the most common questions our guests ask when they visit us, plan an event, or order their favorite Italian dishes.

  • Do you provide curbside pickup for online or phone orders?

    Yes, we provide curbside pickup for both online and phone orders. We know our customers are often balancing busy schedules, so curbside service allows you to enjoy your meal without having to come inside. Just place your order, give us a call when you arrive, and we will bring everything right to your vehicle. Many guests use curbside pickup as an alternative to the best pizza delivery in St Augustine, FL, especially when they want a quick grab-and-go option while still enjoying the same fresh, high-quality food.

  • Can I place an order for same-day or short-notice catering?

    Yes, we offer same-day and short-notice catering whenever our kitchen capacity allows. We understand that last-minute events happen, and we make every effort to accommodate them. Whether you are planning a small office lunch or a family gathering that came together unexpectedly, our team is prepared to create delicious meals quickly and efficiently. While many customers rely on the best pizza delivery in St Augustine, FL for everyday dining, our same-day catering gives you another convenient way to enjoy our food when time is limited.

  • What size groups can your catering services accommodate?

    Our catering services can accommodate gatherings of up to 50 guests. We offer a variety of Italian dishes, pizza options, and meal formats to help you serve groups of different sizes and preferences. Whether you are planning a birthday party, business meeting, family celebration, or community gathering, we can help design a menu that fits your needs. Our goal is to make event planning as simple as possible so you can enjoy your occasion without worrying about the food.

  • Are family-style meals or boxed lunch options available for events?

    Yes, we offer both family-style meals and individually boxed lunches. Family-style meals are ideal for group dining where guests can serve themselves and enjoy a shared experience. Boxed lunches are perfect for workplaces, schools, and events that require individually packaged meals for convenience or safety. Each format includes a variety of Italian favorites prepared fresh in our kitchen. We want you to have flexible choices so your event setup works exactly the way you need it to.

  • Do you use locally sourced ingredients in your dishes?

    Yes, we are proud to use locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Our commitment to freshness is one of the foundations of our menu, and it is a big part of what gives our dishes their signature flavor. From our pizza dough and sauces to toppings, salads, and entrees, we work with local partners to bring high-quality ingredients to your table every day. This dedication to quality is also one of the reasons customers consider us part of the best pizza delivery in St Augustine, FL and continue to support us after more than 25 years in the community.

  • What other Italian favorites are available besides pizza?

    While New York-style pizza is at the heart of what we do, our menu includes a wide selection of Italian favorites. You can enjoy appetizers, fresh salads, and classic Italian entrees that pair perfectly with your pizza or stand on their own as a full meal. Our recipes are based on long-standing family traditions, and we take great pride in offering options that appeal to a wide variety of tastes. Whether you are stopping in for a quick slice or ordering a full spread for the family, we have something to satisfy every appetite.

  • Can I order a single slice, or do you only offer whole pies?

    Yes, you can order a single slice. We serve individual slices for customers who want a quick meal or prefer to sample different flavors without committing to a full pizza. Whether you're on your lunch break or just craving a small bite, we make it easy to enjoy exactly what you're in the mood for.

  • How far in advance should I book catering for larger gatherings?

    For larger gatherings, we recommend booking as early as possible so we can prepare the right menu, ingredients, and portions for your event. While we do offer same-day and short-notice catering, advance notice gives us more flexibility to meet special requests and ensures the smoothest experience for you and your guests.

  • Do you offer takeout options for customers on the go?

    Yes, we offer several takeout options, including in-store pickup, curbside pickup, and delivery. Whether you're picking up dinner for the family or grabbing something quick between errands, we make takeout simple and efficient. Many of our guests use these services alongside the best pizza delivery in St Augustine, FL depending on what works best for their day.

  • What makes your New York-style pizza different from other places?

    Our New York-style pizza stands out because we use time-honored family recipes, fresh locally sourced ingredients, and traditional preparation techniques that create the perfect balance of crisp crust, rich sauce, and flavorful toppings. Every pizza is made by hand, just the way we’ve been doing it for more than 25 years.